November 4th, 2008, marked a great milestone in American history and the history of people of African descent. For the first time in the history of mankind, a junior senator of African heritage got elected to the office of the President of the United States of America. It was a moment of jubilation and thrill…the euphoria was felt around the world. Millions wept out of happiness and for witnessing the unimagined prospect of an African-American president in a once the most racist nation on earth.
That great ecstasy was deeply felt in Africa more than any other place outside the United States. A young senator, whom many in Africa referred to as a native son, won the highest trophy ever imaginable. From the streets of Kogelo – Obama’s ancestral village, to the Cape of Good Hope in South Africa and anywhere in between, the jubilation was rampant.
Just like the triumph, expectations for a favorable American policy towards Africa were high in the air. Even African dictators, ironically the very people who have denied freedom to Africans and condemned them to a miserable life by failing to tackle or exacerbating the issues of corruption, mismanagement, environmental degradation, mal-governance, abuse of power, conflict, poverty and what not, praised Obama’s historic victory one after another. The worst of African dictators jumped on the bandwagon glorifying and praising Obama’s victory as historic and momentous. Here are few such praises from African leaders:
Mr. Moi Kibaki, President of Kenya described Obama´s victory as a “momentous occasion for Kenya…it is our own victory because of his roots here in Kenya… as a country, we are full of pride for his success…your victory is not only an inspiration to millions of people all over the world, but it has special resonance with us here in Kenya.”
Nigerian President Oumaru Yar´Adua…”the election of Barack Obama … has finally broken the greatest barrier of prejudice in human history. I believe for us in Nigeria, we have a lesson to draw from this historic event…that the election of Obama had “created a totally and completely new era.”
Denis Sassou Nguesso described Obama´s victory as a “…moving historic moment…we see how visionaries like Martin Luther King saw coming events. His dream has come true.”
Chad’s National Assembly Leader; Nasser Guelindoksia agreed that Obama´s victory “…is an example to follow, especially by Africans as Americans show that democracy knows no color, religion or origin.”
Somalia’s former President of the Transitional Somali Government, Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed defined Obama´s victory as “…a great moment for America and for Africa…I am hopeful that he (President Obama) will help end the major crisis in the world, particularly the endless conflict in my country.”
Sudanese President Omer Hassan Al-Beshir noted “…we would hope that the slogan of President Obama – change – would be reflected in the foreign policy of the United States…we would like to see some real change between Sudan and the United States.”
South African President Kgalema Motlanthe expressed “…your election…carries with it hopes for millions of your country men and women as much as it is for millions of people of … African descent.”
Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe wrote “…as the government and people of Zimbabwe join you in celebrating this event in the history of the U.S.A, I take this opportunity to assure you Mr. President-elect that the Government of the Republic of Zimbabwe remains ready to engage your government in any desirable endeavor to improve our bilateral relations”.
During his rigorous campaign season, Obama vowed to change American policy towards Africa. Among other things, Obama called on “Ethiopia and Eritrea to walk back from the brink of war which seemed unavoidable at the time…called for an increased pressure on Robert Mugabe to follow through with power-sharing agreement…promised to end the genocide in Darfur… pledged to formulate a new approach to the deteriorating situation in Somalia…strengthen Africom to promote peace, security, and stability on the continent.”
Obama raised the bar even higher in his inaugural speech when he declared “to those who cling to power through corruption and deceit and the silencing of dissent, know that you are on the wrong side of history; but that we will extend a hand if you are willing to unclench your fist…to all those watching tonight (January 20, 2009) from beyond our shores, from parliaments and palaces …huddled around radios in the forgotten corners of our world – our stories are singular, but our destiny is shared, and a new dawn of American leadership is at hand…those who seek peace and security – we support you.”
Today, after 100 full days in office, Obama got an A or B on most of the things he has accomplished so far and for keeping most of his campaign promises. In his own words Obama acknowledged that he is “pleased with what has been accomplished so far, but we have got a lot of work to do”. Most commentators/journalists based their grading on wide range of issues but notably on the economy, transition into power, hiring scrambles, Afghanistan and Pakistan, Environment, Women Rights, Health care, Transparency and Accountability, Bipartisanship, the Closure of Guantanamo Prison and etc.
I wanted to look at what Obama folks have accomplished the African policy conundrum in their first hundred days in office. Practically, nothing. I am not aware of any major campaigns by the African Diaspora or African interest groups with the exception of Save Darfur Coalition that had an agenda for the President in an effort to hit the ground running. Rather a whole host of expectations that the Obama people would be favorable in their approach towards African issues; Hunger, Poverty, HIV, corruption, democracy, regional Peace and Stability etc that are not addressed. There is no doubt that the financial meltdown and the many challenges Obama has inherited from his predecessor has overshadowed his African and other policy initiatives [IV]. But it seems to me that the no-drama Obama team could have done a lot better if they moved “swiftly and quickly” as they have promised us – the enthusiastic supporters.
The visit of Senator John Kerry to Sudan and U.S. Rep. Donald Payne – chairman of the Africa subcommittee on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, to Mogadishu and the dramatic saga of Somali Pirates were among the few major African news makers involving the current U.S Administration.
John Kerry’s visit to Khartoum pushed the Sudanese government to agree to allow some of the expelled humanitarian and aid agencies back to Darfur. The piracy incident was hailed by many as Obama’s first national security test that he proficiently passed. There were also reports that the Obama administration is rethinking its Somalia strategy and Defense Secretary Robert Gates went as far as stating “…the ultimate solution for piracy is on land… there is no purely military solution to it…” and the instability and lawlessness in Somalia is key to the problem.
Whereas the insurgents fired mortar at Representative Payne’s plane, there was little coverage of the purpose and result of the visit. But the congressman stated that “…the policy of constructive engagement [is] where you deal with the government, and let them deal with their internal problem” is essential to curbing piracy off the Somali coast. He added “…the Somali government doesn’t want Americans to come run any nation-building programs…they want technical assistance… they need financial support, and they’ll take care of it for themselves.”
Very few journalists/pundits considered African Policy in their grade report/card. Bruce A. Dixon for the Black Agenda Report, one of the few people I have seen grading the President on African policy, gave him one out of five [vii]. I do not know if there are major initiatives in the works for Obama’s African policy. I sincerely hope so. But based on the selection of Ambassador Jonny Carson, a career diplomat noted for a track record of working in Africa, as Assistant Secretary State for African Affairs, I give the President a passing grade with an optimism that the administration will soon move “swiftly” to act on some of the pressing African issues and fulfill Obama’s campaign promises. It should also be noted here that Obama has followed through with his campaign promise to double overseas USAID which will be valuable in achieving the so called “Millennium Development Goals”. Of course only if African leaders can use it for intended, and most of the time unintended, purposes [viii].
American foreign policy on Africa usually focused disproportionately on short-term stability by embracing dictators. The Bush administration went even farther by subordinating the promotion of human rights, democracy and the rule of law to terrorism concerns, a practice very much reminiscent of cold-war tactics, and thereby alienated the vast majority of freedom seeking Africans. In a recent article Jason McLure of the Newsweek detailed how cunning and enterprising African leaders like Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia used US concerns about terrorism not only to silence his domestic political opposition but also wage a costly war on another already battered and failed African state, Somalia, with huge humanitarian, financial and political cost. After 100 days in office Obama did not even indicate if he would make a departure from this approach that failed both Africans and Americans or continue with it with a slight twist by default.
In short, it remains to be seen if the Obama Administration’s policies will match the rhetoric, the great expectations and the universal goodwill that the President enjoys! Africans of all walks of life are looking up to him to deliver them from repression, war, poverty and HIV/Aids.
Ultimately it is up to Africans not Obama, to fix Africa’s mess. But a just, foresighted and generous hand of a powerful President of the powerful country won’t hurt.
9 thoughts on “First 100 Days – Obama African Report Card: D”
Mr. Oromsis Adula I thank you very much for putting our African case clear.Thank you Elias for posting it.
I recall reading a Washingtonpost article about African immigrants in the US. The writer commented that Africans are few in number in the US and they have a very insignificant impact on the vote. Perhaps, I would add, they would likely vote for him whether he pledges to do something in Africa or not. If you look at Cuba for example they are enormous voting block in Florida. That is exactly why Obama is so passionate about Cuba. Ethiopian government is more repressive than Cuba-that is for sure. Sudanese situation is more pressing than anything else in the world. Zimbabweans are in hell for all what we know. Do we cost a voting block or a bellwether in any forthcoming election? The answer is no. Then why does he and his enthrones care. How many of them know Africa? For me the difference between Susan Rice and C. Rice are the same-they belong to the same old school. My friend, you put it very well, it is up to US not Obama. I expect less, sorry.
Leave Obama alone. He has his hands full already with America’s domestic and foreign issues that need his immediate and undivided attention. Before grading him on the basis of what he has done in the areas of issues that directly affects Africa, Africa itself should be graded first on its own merits.
1) Does Africa have natural resources that are needed for development? Score = A
2) Does it have enough trained human resources for development? Score = B
3) Does it have human resources as labor force needed for development? Score = A
4) Does every country have good governance needed for development? Score = F
5) Is it getting sufficient foreign aid to jump start sustainable development? Score = A+ For more than 200 years.
This continent has made two scenarios as its fate. 1) Have all the ingredients for development or 2) Descend into a continent of failed states. What we see is the #2 scenarios with the least likely of South Africa and that is a matter of time. Just look what is happening in Zimbabwe. Just look at it. This old fart will keep blaming the UK while running the country to the ground. And wait and see what will start happening in South Africa after the 2010 World Cup. When you look at the level of crime and the breakdown of law and order in the areas where the majority of the population reside, it is a matter of time before the haves will start packing and go some where else. Then Zuma will be crowned the new king of the Zulu when the country is brought down to the dust bin. I beseech you to wait and see.
I will wait to hear what some of you think about my comment.
Obama African Report Card – D?
Oh Please! Show me the contract where you hired Obama to fix African problems. Get a job please!
Mr. Moussa!!!
Amen!!! May God Bless you for such an enlightened understanding!!!!
Some people just have to have some one to blame on. They keep blaming USA, All The Western Countries, Russia, China, Belize, Honduras, Chicago, The Tornado that hit the Midwest US in 1974 !!! All of these are the reasons for all our ills and weaknesses!!!! What copouts!!!! If the Western and Eastern powers gave their interests a priority, I say God Bless them!!! I am sick and tired of hearing these lazy bums’ useless excuses.
Dear Blame Generation Members !
I fully Agree with Gebra ‘ s finest analysis and conclusion.
The main obstacle democratic development of the african continent in General Ethiopia in particular is the lack democratic leadership and democratic Governance . In order to achieve the democratic governance we all have to be commited ourselves for the Ideals of democracy. Unfortunately the blame Generation is continuing blaming others. Do we have the courage and the kind of commitment to stand fight in unison against the dictators in our respective Country ? As to me the blame Generation still blaming others for the general problems facing our continent.Democratic governance is a product genuine commitment to democracy and democratic Ideals. it can not imported from a rich a developed countries. For Ethiopian blamers I have a sincere advice. Stand together , Listen each other , Coordinate your efforts, Work in unison create a commen language against the ethno totalitarians and Finally hammer out your differences and fight for a genuine democratic Change in Ethiopia!
If We are capable to show our united effort and strength the Obamas’ and like will come to resque our continent !
Let Almight God Give us the kind of wisdom to listen each other !
Stop Blaming other and workout to hammer out your weakness !
Melkt Lerasse
YES YES YES! Obama deserves ” Double FF” towards Africa. after 100 days, he didn’t do anything…”NADA”
Gabra
Good point you have there. Your emphasis is to do it ourselves and not to blame others for our demise, an argument you succintly make in your short analysis. Your point of crime in RSA and the unaccountability of the old man in Zimababwe is well taken. One issue I suggest you revisit is your point # 5 about foreign aid in jump starting African economies as it touches on your implied reliance on external forces rather than self initiated, home grown, slow but gradual path to growth.
KM
Mr Oromsis beautifully summed his piece that it is US not Obama who will deliver us from the misery we are in, much of it is our own making.
The point, however, is the United States or Obama can’t have the moral ground if they continue to talk and act like as if they are the last best hope or beacon of the world if they don’t match their words with some deeds.
No one is blaming Obama or the West for Africa’s failure. It is, however, a moral imperative for Obama to at least speak up when the African ‘Hippos’ kill and continue to decimate their own people.