Skip to content

History will be unkind to those who cuddle with dictators

Below is a powerful letter addressed to Professor Joseph E. Stiglitz who has invited Ethiopia’s genocidal tyrant to Columbia University to talk about “leadership” in Africa.

– – – – –

Joseph E. Stiglitz
University Professor
Uris Hall, Room 814, Columbia University
3022 Broadway, New York, NY 10027

Phone: +1 (212) 854-1481
Email: [email protected] [email protected]

Dear professor Stiglitz,

It is with a great sense of dismay and incredulity that we learned about the invitation extended to Prime Minister Meles Zenawi of Ethiopia as a keynote speaker to launch “The World and Africa” series organized by your Committee on Global Thought (CGE) at Columbia.

By any measure of good governance, Prime Minister Zenawi stands as one of the most vicious dictators and corrupt leaders of the modern era.

As recently as May of this year, he stunned the democratic world by declaring a 99.6% victory in an election that was characterized by fraud, intimidation, deceit and coercion. As documented by all credible human rights groups and other international observers, in the run-up to the elections, which were reminiscent of the dark days of communism and fascism, he utterly incapacitated all potential threats to his monopoly of power and subjected the populace to unimaginable degrees of social and economic suffering and political repression.

Earlier in 2005, he had violently suppressed another popular movement for democracy, massacred over 193 peaceful protesters, incarcerated all opposition leaders, and sent to concentration camps thousands of suspected members of opposition groups. To this day, one of the most popular leaders of the opposition, Birtukan Mideksa, is languishing in prison on trumped-up charges.

As a man of letters, we trust that you are all too familiar with the Prime Minister’s appalling records on academic freedom. In Zenawi’s Ethiopia, universities and other institutions of learning are under a state of siege. Absolute loyalty to the ethno-centric regime is a pre-requisite for admission to colleges, and consideration for employment requires card-holding membership to the ruling party. Armed cadres planted among the students openly terrorize those with views that are at variance with the party line, and peaceful protests in campuses are violently crushed, as was the case, for example, on April 18, 2001 when the Special Forces police opened fire on a peaceful protest at Addis Ababa University and killed at least 41 people and wounded 250, or when in January of 1993, hundreds of students were shot and mutilated by Zenawi’s police for peacefully exercising their freedom of expression.

As a respected economist and Nobel Prize laureate, we have no doubt in your appreciation of the spurious growth figures Zenawi fabricates to attract foreign aid, while the country he has governed with an iron fist for two decades ranks at the bottom of the developing world with respect to every index of human development. Despite the billions of dollars in aid that he has amassed and embezzled since he snatched power from another dictator, a recent report placed Ethiopia as the second poorest nation in the world, with 90% of the population living in poverty, and 61.5% deprived of adequate schooling.

We do understand your close partnership with the despot, and your effort to give him legitimacy in the aftermath of his dubious 99.6% victory. The people of Ethiopia still remember the similar effort by your colleague, Jeffrey Sachs, who came to Zenawi’s rescue with the Yara Prize following his crushing defeat in the 2005 elections. Nonetheless, we believe that the motive of giving the dictator a cover for his crimes against humanity through a platform at Columbia University would be inconsistent with the image of the university as a bulwark of human rights, social justice and good governance.

We, therefore, ask that you demonstrate your sensitivity to the plights of the millions of Ethiopians who are suffering under the yolk of dictatorship by withdrawing the invitation extended to Zenawi and using the forum instead for a more genuine discourse on the promotion of democracy and good governance in that part of the world.

The world has never forgiven those intellectuals who willfully embraced and promoted Hitler’s atrocious policies that resulted in the extermination of millions of innocent lives. The verdict of history will be equally unkind on the erudite of our time that collude and cuddle with dictators at the expense of the suffering of millions in one of the poorest countries in the world.

Sincerely,

Selam Beyene, Ph.D.
[email protected]

cc:

President Lee Bollinger
202 Low Library
535 West 116th Street, Mail Code 4309
New York, NY 10027 [email protected]

University Programs and Events
Office of the President
Columbia University in the City of New York
202 Low Library
535 West 116th Street
New York, NY 10027
Email: [email protected]

Office of the Secretary of the University
The Trustees of Columbia University
211 Low Library
535 West 116th Street
Mail Code 4324
New York, NY 10027
[email protected]

Columbia Daily Spectator
2875 Broadway, Suite 303, New York, NY 10025
Email: [email protected]

Editor, The New York Times
[email protected]

7 thoughts on “History will be unkind to those who cuddle with dictators

  1. Dr. Selam Beyene, thank you, thank you for sending this excellent letter. Let’s hope many more Ethiopian scholars follow suit, and be a voice for the voiceless Ethiopians.

  2. There is no other worse tyrant than ethiopian/eritrean review’s “editor” Elias Kifle who does not even tolerate to post comments written by people who have different views. You always cry about tyrany and disent but you can’t even accommodate such comments.But you blame a world class leader from speaking his views. More over this is a free country and there are many Ethiopians who would like the PM to speak at the university. It is disgusting that a few of you (who by the way seem to have plenty of time) pretend to represent the majority. Sad very sad.This is what makes us backward.Even worse are the so called intellectuals who sing with this site blindly. Shame on Ethiopian/Eritrean review and its blind followers/haters.
    God Bless Ethiopia

  3. Thank you Dr.Selam, God Bless you for these highly remarkable letter, it made me so proud just to think that there still are intelligent intellectual Ethiopians like you.

  4. Will Dr.Beyene be able to register in advance to participate and interrogate the hell out of this criminal?To confront him in places like that would show the world how necked he really is.

  5. mengesha, we can clearly see that your views are accomodated.About meles being a world class leader is one of the funniest assesments one can make. If meles is a world class leader then I´m a world class chinese chef. If there´re many ethiopians who would like to see meles speak at the university, then they should start their own website and propagate for that. Or do u mean that the freedom u speak about doesn´t apply to Elias? that ER represents the majority can easily be gleaned from the myriad of posts who agree with this sight. Your likes are the minority. It´s obvious, even the blind can see. Your beloved leader ruled for 20 years but still, as u yourself says the country is backward. So who´s to blame? 20 years is a lot of time to change things. U better wake up and smell the coffee instead of blindly following and supporting a documented, genocidal tyrant.

  6. #5 Germa,
    I am afraid, some of the sits that is reserved for outside guests might be already taken with the supporters of tyrant Meles. Since the Woyanes knew ahead of time than the rest of us about Meles‘s speaking engagement, I am pretty sure, his supporters will make sure that, their murderer leader will not be questioned, confronted and challenged by well educated and well informed Ethiopians and let their murderer woyane leader put in the spot and gets humiliated.

Leave a Reply