Skip to content

Is Ethiopia’s Meles Zenawi next on ICC’s indictment list?

By MICHELLE FAUL

JOHANNESBURG (AP) – The International Criminal Court’s decision to pursue a sitting head of state on war crimes charges puts others around the world on notice, but it’s also raising questions about which leaders are being targeted.

International human rights organizations accuse Ethiopia’s dictator Meles Zenawi of crimes against humanity

African and Arab nations say they will support Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir, fearing the warrant issued against him Wednesday will bring even more conflict in Darfur, where up to 300,000 people have died since 2003, and further destabilize Sudan.

And they question why only Africans have been charged since the ICC — branded “the white man’s court” by Sudan’s information ministry –€” began its work six years ago. A temporary court, the tribunal for the former Yugoslavia, indicted Slobodan Milosevic in 1999 while he was still president of Yugoslavia.

The chairman of the 52-state African Union has accused the court of “double standards,” asking why no cases have emerged from conflicts in the Caucasus, Iraq or Gaza.

“The African states were the strongest supporters of establishing the ICC. It wouldn’t have been possible without them. But there has been a significant shift in the past year,” said Christopher Hall, senior legal adviser to Amnesty International.

Outside Africa, ICC prosecutor Luis Moreno Ocampo is investigating possible cases in Colombia, Georgia and Afghanistan as well as a Palestinian request for charges against Israel for its actions in Gaza.

In Africa, those considered possible targets of the court are leaders in Zimbabwe, Kenya, Uganda, Ethiopia, Chad, Ivory Coast, Rwanda and Central African Republic.

Even among the Africans, the court’s choices are questioned. Why is it prosecuting former Congolese warlord and vice president Jean-Pierre Bemba for alleged crimes his fighters committed in Central African Republic, and not the ousted Central African leader who invited Bemba’s forces?

Why not the many other Congolese warlords whose forces all are accused of gross atrocities, including those of President Joseph Kabila? And what about the leaders in Rwanda, Uganda and other African countries that sent troops to Congo?

“It’s a very uneven path,” said Reed Brody, legal counselor for Human Rights Watch. “We’re still in a situation where if you are powerful or protected by the powerful you can avoid a reckoning.”

South African Nobel laureate Archbishop Desmond Tutu said African leaders are behaving shamefully and dismissed concerns that the court’s action would impede promoting peace.

“Are they on the side of the victim or the oppressor?” Tutu asked in a column in The New York Times. “Rather than stand by those who have suffered in Darfur, African leaders have so far rallied behind the man responsible for turning that corner of Africa into a graveyard.”

Al-Bashir’s presidential adviser, Mustafa Osman Ismail, branded the world’s first permanent international court to investigate war crimes “one of the tools of the new colonization” aimed at destabilizing the sprawling oil-rich nation.

Sudan is Africa’s biggest country, covering an area the size of Western Europe and bridging the continent’s northern Muslim Arabs and southern Christian and animist Africans in a union riven with conflict since independence from Britain in 1956.

In Darfur, the war began in 2003 when rebel ethnic African groups, many of them Muslim, took up arms against the Arab-dominated government they accuse of discrimination and neglect. Up to 300,000 people have died and 2.7 million have been forced from their homes in what the United States calls a genocide.

Those who argue that amnesty is a more powerful weapon for peace, though, point to Ugandan rebel leader Joseph Kony, who defaulted on a peace agreement after the court issued an arrest warrant against him.

In recent months, Kony’s Lord’s Resistance Army is accused of killing more than 1,500 civilians in northeast Congo and driving some 100,000 from their homes.

“There is a balance between attaining justice and sustainable peace,” Uganda’s Foreign Minister Sam Kutesa said Wednesday.

While another rebel leader, Bosco Ntaganda, is wanted by the International Criminal Court for war crimes, Congo chose rather to treat with him and integrate his fighters into the national army. The move appears so far to have diminished the most powerful rebel threat in eastern Congo.

Sudan has reportedly said that African nations opposed to al-Bashir’s arrest warrant would pull out of the ICC in protest, but none had done so as of Thursday.

Thirty of the court’s 108 member states are African. And every indictment it has brought acted on requests from African members — Uganda, Congo and Central African Republic. Al-Bashir’s arrest warrant is the exception, initiated by the U.N. Security Council.

That in itself shows hypocrisy, critics say, given that three of the council’s five permanent members — China, Russia and the United States –€” refuse to join the international court.

The precedent set by the court Wednesday could extend to former U.S. President George W. Bush, amid charges his officials were the architects of criminal detention policies that led to torture in Iraq and at Guantanamo detention center in Cuba. But that is an extremely remote prospect. The Security Council is unlikely to order that while Washington is a veto-wielding permanent member.

“The world’s justice looks with one eye,” complained Taher Nunu, spokesman for Hamas, the Islamic militant group that Israel has been battling in Gaza.”

(Michelle Faul is the AP’s chief of African news.)

11 thoughts on “Is Ethiopia’s Meles Zenawi next on ICC’s indictment list?

  1. The selective justice of ICC would not touch Meles for genocide he perpetutated in Ethiopia, Somalia and Eritrea. He is a trusted agent of the recolonization of Africa. The ICC targets are those who stood to the Reliberation of Africa.

  2. My answer is, No. But his lieutenants, no doubt. At the time when some of his henchmen charged, Melese will be given a green light to escape. I am sure, unlike Saddam, he is smart enough to use the opportunity he is given.

    Don’t doubt it; the charge on those henchmen has nothing to do with justice. They will be used as scapegoat at the time Ethiopia immersed in blood bath. Melese will awarded a free pass for job well done.

    Mengistu is a good example. At the final stage, Mengistu conspired with Ethiopian enemies in dismantling Ethiopia and got a free pass to Zimbabwe leaving behind all his henchmen.

    At that time there was no clear demarcation for Ethiopia to disintegrate. The master plan was in Weyanes hand and well executed in the last 18 years.

  3. I think ICC is on the right track. I have no heart for African rulers, who shoot at their own people to rule them under the yoke of fear and terror. They do not deserve to be called leaders because they do not have the character of a leader. They are armed and organized official terrorists and murderers. How can one treat his own people with disrespect and yet claim to be their leader.

    The world must stand with all African people who are fighting for their freedom. If they were real leaders they would be protected by their people. Instead the Ethiopian people and other Africans alike would be happy to hand over the likes of Meles & Co. to ICC overnight.

  4. Don’t fool yourself. ICC is only after those leaders who oppose the Western dominantion in Africa. – Like Mugabe who distributed the land to native Africans. Those leaders like Meles who serve (Western interest will be labeled “democrat” and they will be under their protection whatever they do against their people.

  5. Don’t fool yourself. ICC is only after those leaders who oppose the Western dominance in Africa. – Like Mugabe who distributed the land to native Africans. Those leaders like Meles who serve western interest will be labeled “democrats” and they will be under their protection whatever they do against their people.

  6. I hope they take this dracula’s sorry ass to one of the middleage dungeons in Europe and feed him the all ‘delicious’ ‘beles’ – quulqual – he is used to.

  7. ICC is doing a great job. The dictatorial regimes who want to cover their crimes with age-old and long forgotten
    “colonization” “western influence” etc don’t hold water. This is the question of human rights. Africans are human beings too. I believe the next criminal in the ICC line-up is the butcher of Africa, Meles Zenawi.

  8. My brothers and sisters please stop dreaming unless we brought this son of bitch to justice no body will.Let us work toward that.How many Ethiopian die every day?Killing is not only pulling a trigger.Please look around.Is there any body who did not see a woman without dark cloths.She is telling you she lost a husband,sons,doughters,a father or a mother.What do you gone do about it?Join hands and get rid off this goat looking creature and all his stoogs.

  9. If we want peace reconciliation and justice in Ethiopia we need to capture Meles in Addis. If he runs somewhere it is the responsibility and the right of Ethiopians to make sure that him and other criminals shall appear in court for the genocide they committed.

    Massacring and looting should not be a fun for TPLF. So, ICC your next target is meles. work with Ethiopians.

Leave a Reply