We, the current generation of Ethiopians, as a society should be ashamed of our inability to provide food for millions of our children. The latest estimate is that over 6 million Ethiopians are facing starvation and millions of children are malnourished, while the so-called “government” of Ethiopia is selling the country’s fertile land to Saudi Arabia and India so that they can secure food for their people. And yet a group of Ethiopian tour companies, 25 of them, are currently up in arms against BBC’s coverage of the food shortage in Ethiopia (see below a report by Ash Smyth). These companies could be owned by Ethiopia’s vampire regime that is sucking the life blood of our country. BBC is doing a good job in exposing the starvation in Ethiopia that the regime and its opportunist friends try to hide. The ongoing starvation in Ethiopia should put the regime, and every Ethiopian, to shame.
Ethiopian tour operators attack BBC’s doom-laden coverage
By Ash Smyth (The First Post): Ethiopian tour operators, in London for this month’s World Travel Market, have addressed a furious open letter to the BBC’s Director General, concerning the Corporation’s recent coverage of the drought in Ethiopia. The letter, signed by some 25 companies, accuses the BBC of casually dramatising its broadcasts with footage from the infamous 1984 famine.
“Ethiopia,” they wrote, “has changed beyond all recognition since 1984, yet the BBC insists on showing images from that time. They are very intrusive and are deeply upsetting to many millions of Ethiopians.”
[Ethiopia has changed only for the few Woyannes and their collaborators.]
But beyond the matter of stung pride, the tour operators insist that the “doom-laden scenario” implied by the BBC’s use of old newsreel damages the national image, deterring foreign investment and scaring off tourists. “Investment, trade and tourism are key to Ethiopia’s development,” they claim “more so than aid.”
[BBC runs old newsreel because the regime does not allow reporters to videotape the current famine.]
Which is true. The tourism industry currently accounts for approximately five per cent of Ethiopia’s GDP and tourism is a “featured component” of the government’s Poverty Reduction Strategy. With about 400,000 tourists a year, the country is still not exactly a hotspot, but adroit marketing of events like the 2007 ‘millennium’ and the annual Addis ‘Marathon’ (10km) have seen visitor numbers increase steadily over the last five years (visitors, incidentally, who invariably comment on how green the country is).
[It is true, the country is green and fertile. So do not say the starvation in Ethiopia is due to rain shortage and drought. That is a lie told by the regime and repeated by poverty-mongers like the World Bank. The problem is that the regime is busy stealing the country’s wealth, instead of governing.]
The Ethiopians are not hiding the scale of the current problem, either – they can’t afford to. Poor rains in the first six months of this year, above-average food prices, and shrinking levels of routine foreign aid, have resulted, by the government’s own figures, in 6.2 million empty mouths. [This is a lie. poor rain is not the cause of food shortage in Ethiopia. If so, why do Saudi and Indian companies come, grow wheat and corn in Ethiopia and export them to their countries?]
Just to see out the rest of 2009, Ethiopia will need some 350,000 metric tonnes of additional foodstuffs: $120m worth.
But “there will not be famine again in Ethiopia,” promises Prime Crime Minister Meles Zenawi. The state has built (with Chinese assistance, of course) more than 100,000km of new roads to facilitate distribution, shelled out for more food, arranged for the berthing of extra supply ships in Djibouti, and increased trucking capacity. “The government has an efficient early warning system and keeps stores of food for times of shortfall.”
[Is that why millions of children are malnourished in Ethiopia?]
Unfortunately, though, Ethiopia’s shortfall policies can still only cater for a couple of million people in a good year. Moreover, these are all emergency measures, addressing the results of food crises, not the causes.
Ethiopia’s constant need for aid stems largely from increasingly frequent droughts, wars both internal and external, and a population (thanks, ironically, to all the improvements of the last quarter-century) expanding by two million a year. But it is also the result of bad agricultural policies.
[There is no drought in Ethiopia. The problem is mismanagement and only mismanagement of the country by the regime that is run by village idiots.]
Chief among these is the fact that all land is state-owned (a hangover, perhaps tellingly, from previous famine-struck eras). This stifles growth, since farmers can’t take out loans against the land, and fosters inefficient subdivision as plots are endlessly divided through the generations.
The result is that, in one of the fastest-growing economies in the world (according to Economist [false] predictions), the agricultural sector employs 80 per cent of the workforce and yet 40 per cent of the country lives below the poverty line; agriculture accounts for half of Ethiopia’s GDP and one of her chief imports is food.
Ethiopians, meanwhile, tend to blame donor nations for dumping grain on them, rather than giving them cash to buy it locally. My enquiries also met with a reminder that more than 12m Britons receive government subsidy of some kind (which would have been a neat comeback if, given the circumstances, the correspondence hadn’t also sported the line: “Ethiopia, the water tower of Africa”).
But whatever the immediate cause of the current crisis, the BBC’s lazy Geldof-ite coverage certainly isn’t helping its effect. Worse, it is not the first time this has happened. In 2004, Michael Buerk’s ’20th anniversary’ broadcasts prompted a raft of cancellations from prospective visitors under the impression that famine was once again rife. Again, Ethiopian tour operators complained.
To date, neither letter has had a response. The BBC well deserves the rap on the knuckles and the Ethiopians deserve an apology.
6 thoughts on “Ethiopia: Our shame cannot be covered up”
Elias;
Why are you so angry whenever people tell good about Ethiopia from their first hand observation (not from distant like you)? How can you Isayas, and Al Shabab become always right while Ethiopians, Diplomats, USA, UK, EU, World Bank, UN, India, China, Sudan, Kenya, Djibouti, Middle East, get it wrong?
Some times you must admit the truth- it might be soaring, but it is a truth. Bear with it.
I know you are not posting it (because you are a coward to face truth). But it is meant to feed your malnourished judgment, as usual.
By the way why did the author hide his name ?
I am sure he is an Ethiopian,but maybe a kind of british worshipper Ethiopian, why i say that ?
Because he defends the BBC.
So let us know the name of the writer.
In addition the guy is misleading us,first famine is created by Meles for political reasons, and Meles is supported by the british government which controls the BBC. So we can say BBC is crying about a problem it(that is to say the british government through their support of Meles ) has created,and that is pure hypocrisy.
So the unnamed author was supposed to address this hypocrisy,but he did not do it because he has reasons,sure not noble ones.
And let us not forget that the repeated use of the Tigre famine victims by BBC is for psychological warfare reasons, the british not only hope using those famished Tigre pictures they can attack the proud Ethiopians and harm the country, also the pride of other Africans and blacks. In addition the british are instrumentalizing the famished Tigres to divert attention from their own great problems, as britain is declining economically and politically following the recent financial crisis.
Imagine how many millions british would starve to death if there was no social benefit ?
Unfortunately, as for every action their is an equal and opposite reaction the british are already suffering or will suffer an equal size of damage they have inflicted on Ethiopia,Africa and the black race,sorry that the british have to pay one way or another. And sorry that one of those victims would be the english language. Another victim is the BBC itself, as it is no longer credible.
Really sad for the british.
Apart from the fact that the author is not making the british and the West responsible for imposing such a dictator on Ethiopians and does not go even as far as accusing them of genocide he or she is right when he or she said that drought is not the cause of famine. Imagine most countries,including all our neighbours, get less water than Ethiopia. The cause is the government’s policies. And he is also right when he said that the regime creates intentionally the food shortage problem
and use it as a tool to stay in power,and that shows the barbarian nature of the regime that was imposed on Ethoipians by the West.
The truth should be told as is, though it hurts.Monkey will always remain monkey and the ethiopian monkeys are doing exactly what monkeys do best. Monkey bussines. KIMALIM SURI YASFETAL WEYANEM SURACHIHUN ASFETOTCHIWAL especialy the ethiopian comtoes in diaspora namely,the amara Hodamoch.Now it is not time to lament now it is time to pick up your guns and wipe out the weyane gangs from the face of the beautiful ethiopa, for the wyane are the eye sore of this great country.
Endee!! Dear writer!! Believe me I hate this government! And I am not a fan of this stupid opposition parties either. But I want Ethiopia to rise; I don’t want her name to be dirtied unnecessarily. If it is a true report (regarding election 2005, Issue of Ogaden and general human right issue)….yes…i would very much like to see the government being exposed. But..there is a limit to everything… If you love your country dear writer, you should be not be defending what BBC is doing!! Showing a 25year old image for a dramatical impact is hardly an expose. Why not show the current image if they are doing an expose then? Is it perhaps because it is not as striking as they want? Of course! Just because you hate this government people please please don’t wish the people who are still live there and our beloved country the worst imaginable scenario!
[Yes—we should feel ashamed that the famine is going on! But still….
“Investment, trade and tourism are key to Ethiopia’s development,” they claim ¬ “more so than aid.”]
You put this on quotation?? Really? You think Aid will save us and not investment, trade and tourism?? If your answer is yes..then I shall not continue as I don’t wish to discuss with a person who thinks like this. …… I wish the aid stops today! Now!..then the government and the people would have acted towards coming up with some sort of solution…but why right? Cause….BBC will splash the 1984 pics every single f***ing year we have shortage and donors will come running with money and the investement that would have happened to save few thousands of people will be lost……shall I be thankful to BBC hell no! I hope their company burns to the ground!(ofcourse all the ppl out :)
Elias: thank you for posting this and keeping us update about the atrocities in that country. I personally can not wait until I read something about Ethiopia form ER. I strongly respect respect your position and I do share your frustrations. however, after your wrote the ediotiral please avoid guiding us how to read. We do know what to make of the stories. no deleting please. I know you run the website but I feel that the story need to be kept as it is. Freedom of press begins here. Thanks again!
Do u know how westerns percieve us?
For your surprise they asked me whether we use tooth brush or not in Ethiopia. So sad.
I wish to take all westerss to ethiopia to show them how beautiful we are.
Religion, culture, historical places, rivers, fountains, monastries, diferent languages, ethicities,